Accidental Education (Why Bad Education is Still Good)

In a perfect world, school curriculum would includedifferent expectations. Over the course of their
interesting, relevant and useful lessons that wouldschool-age years, kids will be exposed to great, good,
inspire students to learn, develop and seek morefair and poor teachers. Learning to cope with the
education.weak ones may, ultimately, teach them more than
But, alas, we live on Earth where perfect exists only inwhat they learn from the strong ones. It's the Knight
our imagination. As anyone who has ever been toeffect. Legendary (and controversial) basketball coach
school knows, a lot of what's taught there is boring,Bobby Knight was so difficult to play for that, after
irrelevant and useless.dealing with him, his players could work with anyone.
The result? Kids hate school. They hate it so much2. Smart students adapt to their classmates. In our
they quit. In the United States, 7,000 kids drop out ofpublic schools, kids are randomly thrown together into
school each day. That's one every nine seconds. Oneincredibly diverse clusters. I'm always amazed at how
out of four American high school freshmen won'twell my socially successful students adjust to the
graduate with his or her class. When you consider theiridiosyncratic propensities of their peers. Again, perfect
frustration with our flawed educational system, it'sclassmates are nice, but learning how to deal with the
understandable.exasperating ones may spur more growth.
Understandable but still regrettable. Because as3. Strong all-around students - and, right or wrong, kids
twisted and irrational as school can be, it's still good. It'scan't get into college without being sound in all subjects
still important. It's still valuable. Getting a diploma and- must adapt to their different courses' requirements.
getting a degree will always be better than not gettingSome kids are math/science kids. Others are English
it.social science kids. But the best students are
The reason, although easy to understand, is just notindustrious, and that enables them to adapt and make
communicated to kids as much as it should be - thatthe grade in any class, from art to P.E.
battling their way through our imperfect schools4. Tough students gut it out and adapt to the lousy
inadvertently prepares them to battle their way aroundphysical conditions in which they're supposed to learn.
our imperfect planet.They have to endure uncomfortable chairs in crowded,
Obviously, schools won't promote this. "As bad as wetoo hot or too cold classrooms. Too often, their
may be, stick it out because we're preparing you forbathrooms are disgusting and their campuses are ugly.
reality." Yet it's true. Education, sometimes in spite ofThe working conditions at most fast food restaurants
itself, works. For example, it reinforces Darwin's majorare better than the learning conditions at most public
point: Adapt or die! Our less than ideal schoolsschools.
unintentionally teach students how to adapt in fourThink of the thirteen years of California public
ways:education as boot camp for life, because that's pretty
1. Successful students learn how to adapt to differentmuch what it has become. (This is called seeing the
teachers with different styles, different rules andglass as half full).