Why Feng Shui Can't Be Considered a Science

When I first started speaking publicly about feng shui inplan differently. And finally, with all of us having some
1992, I was very enthusiastic about promoting it as ameasure of free will or destiny, we cannot place the
natural science, mostly because I believed it to be so. Iidentical occupants in two separate but equal living
was also reacting to the mounting trendiness of fengspaces. Perhaps the closest we could get would be
shui, as it was being marketed by people who referredoccupants for each house with the same birth dates.
to it as "magic" or a spiritual practice linked to TantricAnd yet, feng shui gets pretty darn close. I call it a
Buddhism. I could not stand these comparisons"predictive art," like astrology, because there are
because I knew they were not true and I also felt theytendencies, strong ones, when certain circumstances
tarnished the integrity of feng shui. I did not want toare similar or when enough variables are identical.
turn off potential clients who could accept feng shui asMy books cover many case studies of certain house
real, but with a clear conscience that it is grounded intypes that I have evaluated, documented and have
laws of nature and a time-tested methodologyseen with great amazement that their "personalities"
transcending Chinese culture. I wanted to educate theare well defined. There are house types that can
public that feng shui theories and principles would notundermine fertility, house types that seem to attract
be in conflict with anyones' spiritual or formal religiouslegal problems to their occupants and house types that
beliefs and is as relevant, or more relevant today, thancan suggest infidelity, just to name a few examples.
its discovery thousands of years ago. That part I stillThere are 144 different house types based on the 20
do believe. Feng Shui is no more in conflict with anyyear era that they have been built in and their
organized religion than say, the laws of gravity. Fengmagnetic compass alignment. For instance, a house
Shui is a natural phenomenon on this planet. But is it abuilt in 1985 facing east is different in its influence than
science?a house built in 2004 facing the same direction. Or a
A friend with an impressive scientific backgroundhouse facing West at 260 degrees is different than a
gently told me years ago that it cannot be consideredhouse facing west at 265 degrees.
a science because the circumstances which weWithin these 144 house types, there could be hundreds,
evaluate and interpret cannot be guaranteed to repeatmaybe thousands, of different basic floor plans. This is
or be identical all of the time. Like a science experimentwhy every house is truly unique. As well, houses
where a set group of compounds are combined withchange their influence on occupants over long periods
a repeatable and identical outcome, feng shui includesof time. A house built in 1903, without any remodeling or
too many variables which cannot be repeated ordecor changes, will affect people differently in 2009.
guaranteed.Houses go through their own "maturation" process and
For example, I can say with confidence that a housethe the biggest cycle repeats every 180 years.
which was built in the 1970's and which faces South isEven though feng shui is not an absolute science, I
one where there is a strong tendency for a couple tohave been impressed at how close it gets, with clients
divorce in. And yet, I cannot guarantee that outcomeconfirming the influence of their home or business
100% of the time or say exactly with 100% accuracybased on the traditional calculations of time and space.
when the separation will occur, even when factoring inWhen I ask the occupants if they are experiencing
annual cycles. With two houses that were built thecertain health issues indicated by their environment, the
same year, same orientation, and same floor plan, weaffirmative response is about 90%. When people
still cannot guarantee the two houses would beexperience a certain event, like a robbery or fire, the
decorated the same way or used the same way. Onetiming of these events can be corroborated with
family might use the Northwest bedroom as an officealmost as much accuracy. In the same way that our
and another might use the Northwest bedroom as aweatherman can predict a 70% chance of rain or a
sleeping room. That alone will change the influence ofpollster can predict the likely outcome of an election,
the houses on the two families. Nor can we repeat thefeng shui can be considered a "predictive art" without
exact same exterior environment. One house mightdiminishing its authenticity, usefulness, and relevancy in
have a park across the street and another house a hill.our modern world.
These outside features would affect the same floor